10/17/1977: The US Lifts Ban on Concorde

[In The News]

DALLAS – Today in Aviation, the US Supreme Court paved the way for immediate trial flights of Concorde to New York’s JFK Airport in 1977. The first flight, without passengers, would be made two days later.

The Supreme Court ruling was the end of “a long and bitter struggle” between the operators of Concorde, who argued that New York operations were needed to make the expensive plane profitable, and the airport operators, community groups of the Kennedy area, and their political representatives. The crux of the struggle: noise pollution.

Opponents argued that the new supersonic transport (SST) was the world’s noisiest plane and that it would be an inadmissible reversal of the steady trend towards stricter noise standards and quieter airport areas to allow it into New York.

Conversely, the proponents contended that the supersonic jet would have only a marginal effect on airport noise, with federal research and experiments to back them up.

Further, the proponents’ main point had always been that the aircraft would comply with noise requirements that had already been in place at JFK for 20 years. All that was needed was for Concorde to prove it.

Concorde 001 first flight. Photo: By André Cros – This photograph is part of the Fonds André Cros, preserved by the city archives of Toulouse and released under CC BY-SA 4.0 license by the deliberation n°27.3 of June 23rd, 2017 of the Town Council of the City of Toulouse., CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=65960901

The Ban on Concorde

---

The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey banned the type from landing at JFK on March 11, 1976. The authorities, however, were not the only group who opposed the SST landing at JFK. Protests started earlier that year when a drive-in of 2,000 cars stopped traffic near the airport.

Air France (AF) and British Airways (BA) found the ban discriminatory and detrimental to Concorde’s operations, as stated in a lawsuit dating June 14, 1977.

The High Court ruled in a procedural decision to reject a request by the Port Authority that it keep the SST ban in effect until a final Supreme Court decision could be made on the overall merits of the Concorde case. On October 17, 1977, The Supreme Court lifted the temporary ban.

The Supreme Court ruling was based on the argument that the Port Authority was “dragging its feet” with an indefinite ban based on no clear noise requirements, and that a significant technical innovation was “in imminent danger of being studied into obsolescence.”

British Airways Concorde G-BOAC. Photo: Eduard Marmet – http://www.airliners.net/photo/British-Airways/Aerospatiale-BAC-Concorde-102/1406076/L/&width=1024&height=699&sok=WHERE__(photographer_%3D_%27Eduard_Marmet%27)&sort=_order_by_photo_id_DESC&photo_nr=67&prev_id=1406077&next_id=1406075, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=5810282

An Arbitrary Rule

---

As a result, the appeals judges amended the district court decision to reaffirm the power of the Port Authority to issue a new regulation, as long as it met the requirement of non-discrimination.

According to The New York Times (1977), a major problem in creating such a rule was that a noise level that would keep the Concorde out of JFK could also keep out a significant portion of the then-existing subsonic jet fleet. Needless to say, that would have had a devastating economic impact on the airport and the airlines using it.

Although Concorde had a cruising speed of 1,350 mph, which halved the trans-Atlantic flight time to three and a half hours, sonic booms would not affect populated communities. By rule, the speed of the aircraft was to be reduced to subsonic levels (to about 600 mph) well before the plane reached the coast.

On an interesting note, President Kennedy had planned to announce the launch of America’s own SST program on June 5, 1963, in a speech to the graduating class at the US Air Force Academy.

As planning for Concorde began much earlier, in 1954, JFK viewed the European SST as a threat to American leadership.

First Flight to JFK

---

Two days after the Supreme Court allowed the supersonic jet to land in New York, Concorde took off from Toulouse (TLS), where the final assembly of the jet was completed by Aerospatiale engineers, for its maiden flight to JFK.

The French-registered Concorde F-WTSB landed at JFK on October 19, 1977. It was received by journalists, mixed-mood spectators, and Port Authority officials who set out to quantify the noise pollution generated by the type. Concorde passed the noise level tests; if it were louder than 112 perceived noise decibels, it would be barred from the airport.

On November 22, 1977, Concorde began regularly scheduled passenger services to JFK.

Air France operated the “White Bird” on daily flights between Paris – Charles De Gaulle and JFK. The Paris flight departed at 10:30 am local time, arriving in New York at 8:25 am local time. The airline also operated the Concorde to Caracas (CCS), during the Venezuelan oil boom, and to Mexico City via Washington and to Rio de Janeiro. 

On its part, British Airways-operated Concorde flights BA 001 and BA 002 to/from JFK, departed LHR at 10:30 am, arriving at 9:30 am local time in New York.

---

Featured image: “White Bird,” Air France Concorde aircraft. Photo: Air France. Article sources: The New York Times, aerotime.aero, thepointsguy.com.

View the full article